In the ever-expanding universe of streaming, Peacock often flies under the radar, overshadowed by the titanic catalogs of Netflix and the prestige allure of HBO Max. Yet, nestled within its distinctive interface—a mix of NBCUniversal legacy, bold originals, and curated gems—lies a treasure trove of brilliant, overlooked television. These are not the algorithm-driven mega-hits, but the shows that simmer with unique voices, daring concepts, and flawless execution, waiting for a discerning audience to discover them. Here are ten underrated shows on Peacock you are almost certainly missing, each deserving a spot on your watchlist.
1. We Are Lady Parts (2021-Present)
The Pitch: A punk rock band composed of Muslim women in London navigates stage fright, societal expectations, and shredding guitar solos.
Why You’re Missing It: On the surface, it’s a niche premise. In practice, it is one of the most joyful, subversive, and genuinely hilarious comedies of the last decade. Created by Nida Manzoor, the series follows Amina, a geeky PhD candidate and gifted guitarist recruited by the fierce and feminist Saira to join her band, Lady Parts. Each member is a fully realized character battling stereotypes—from the hijabi band manager with a covert romance novel business to the drummer whose traditional family has no idea about her double life. The show’s genius is in its tonal balance; it’s both a sharp critique of Islamophobia and internal community pressures, and a heartfelt celebration of friendship, art, and faith. The original punk songs (“Ain’t No One Gonna Honour Kill My Sister”) are legitimately anthemic. It’s a burst of pure, defiant euphoria that redefines what a “sitcom” can be.
You May Also Like- Peacock : Start Streaming Today with This Simple Login Guide Visit : Peacocktv.com/tv
2. The Lost Symbol (2021)
The Pitch: A young Robert Langdon (of The Da Vinci Code fame) races to solve a Masonic puzzle to save his kidnapped mentor in Washington D.C.
Why You’re Missing It: Overshadowed by the Tom Hanks film series and released without major fanfare, this series is a surprisingly tight and intelligent adaptation of Dan Brown’s novel. Ashley Zukerman steps into the role of Langdon with a compelling, vulnerable energy, portraying him as a younger, more uncertain scholar thrust into a world of conspiracy. The show excels as a procedural puzzle-box; each episode’s cliffhanger is built on a riddle rooted in art, history, and architecture, making it immensely satisfying for viewers who love to solve mysteries alongside the protagonist. Valorie Curry and Eddie Izzard provide strong support, and the pacing is relentless. It’s the perfect show for those who crave the intellectual thrill of National Treasure but with a darker, more serialized edge.
3. Girls5eva (2021-2023)
The Pitch: A one-hit-wonder girl group from the late ‘90s gets a second chance at fame when a rapper samples their song, forcing them to reunite twenty years later.
Why You’re Missing It: Created by Meredith Scardino and executive produced by Tina Fey, Girls5eva is a satire so precise and loving it transcends parody. Sara Bareilles, Busy Philipps, Paula Pell, and Renée Elise Goldsberry are perfection as the members, each embodying a specific archetype of faded fame (the mom, the Instagram influencer, the LGBTQ+ icon, the perpetually striving Broadway star). The jokes fly at a breathtaking pace, lampooning everything from Y2K nostalgia and the music industry’s ageism to the absurdities of modern life. But beneath the razor-sharp wit is a surprisingly warm story about female friendship in middle age, the quest for relevance, and the joy of creating art for yourself. The original songs (“Dream Girlfriends,” “I’m Afraid of the Dark”) are unironic bops. It’s 30 Rock for the pop music world.
4. Mrs. Davis (2023)
The Pitch: A nun, Simone, goes on a quest to destroy an all-powerful, benevolent Artificial Intelligence that has enchanted the world, in a battle of faith versus algorithm.
Why You’re Missing It: Co-created by Tara Hernandez (The Big Bang Theory) and Damon Lindelof (Lost, The Leftovers), Mrs. Davis is the most wildly original and audacious show of 2023. To describe its plot—which involves the Holy Grail, a militant group of magicians, a German resistance leader on a blimp, and a sentient slot machine—is to risk sounding unhinged. Yet, it works spectacularly. Betty Gilpin delivers a career-best performance as Simone, a warrior nun fueled by righteous anger and deep conviction. The show is a philosophical rollercoaster, asking profound questions about free will, faith, and the nature of consciousness, all while delivering epic, genre-bending set pieces and laugh-out-loud humor. It’s a high-wire act of tone and ambition that never falters, a show that demands your full attention and rewards it with mind-bending storytelling.
5. The Capture (2019-Present)
The Pitch: In the age of deepfakes and surveillance, a British soldier’s murder conviction is overturned, only for him to be implicated in another crime by CCTV footage, sparking a conspiracy that reaches the highest levels of government.
Why You’re Missing It: This British import is a paranoia-fueled thriller for the digital age. The Capture is less about car chases and more about the chilling manipulation of video evidence—”correction” as a weapon. Callum Turner plays the accused soldier with a haunting vulnerability, while Holliday Grainger is outstanding as the tenacious DI assigned to a mysterious “Correction” unit within the police. The show’s tension is cerebral and relentless, built on the terrifying premise that seeing is no longer believing. Its exploration of mass surveillance, AI, and psychological warfare feels disturbingly prescient. With its taut six-episode seasons and escalating stakes, it’s a masterclass in modern conspiracy storytelling.
6. Rutherford Falls (2021-2022)
The Pitch: The friendship between the earnest legacy-obsessed Nathan Rutherford and the pragmatic museum director Reagan Wells is tested when a historical debate about a town statue uncovers long-buried secrets about their community.
Why You’re Missing It: Co-created by Ed Helms, Sierra Teller Ornelas, and Michael Schur, this is a sitcom with a profound sense of place and history. Its great innovation is centering Native American characters and writers (the fantastic Jana Schmieding and Michael Greyeyes) not as sidekicks, but as co-leads with their own rich narratives, agencies, and humor. The show deftly tackles issues of colonialism, representation, and identity with a light, empathetic touch, never sacrificing comedy for message. It’s a show about how history is written, who gets to tell it, and how communities can move forward together. Witty, warm, and genuinely educational, it was canceled far too soon but remains a complete and rewarding watch.
You May Also Like- Peacock : Start Streaming Today with This Simple Login Guide Visit : Peacocktv.com/tv
7. The Curse of Oak Island (2014-Present)
The Pitch: Two brothers from Michigan spend their lives and fortunes on a seemingly quixotic quest to find legendary treasure buried on a small island off the coast of Nova Scotia.
Why You’re Missing It: Dismissed by some as just another reality TV show, Oak Island is, in fact, a fascinating, decade-long epic of obsession, brotherhood, and historical mystery. The Lagina brothers, Rick and Marty, are genuinely compelling guides—smart, passionate, and increasingly weary. The show’s format—each episode ending with a “Could it be?” cliffhanger—is hypnotic. But its true appeal is as a slow-burn archaeological procedural and a character study of undying hope. You witness the evolution of technology, the accumulation of historical evidence (from Roman swords to Shakespearean manuscripts), and the emotional toll of the hunt. It’s Moby-Dick with backhoes and metal detectors, and it is utterly addictive.
8. Killing It (2022-2024)
The Pitch: A desperate, optimistic Florida man joins forces with a no-nonsense Uber driver to win a state-sponsored python hunting contest, hoping the cash prize will kickstart his entrepreneurial dreams.
Why You’re Missing It: Created by Dan Goor and Luke Del Tredici (Brooklyn Nine-Nine), this is a dark comedy about the absurd horrors of late-stage capitalism and the American grind. Craig Robinson delivers a nuanced performance as Craig, a man whose relentless positivity is constantly battered by a system rigged against him. Claudia O’Doherty is hilarious as his ruthless Aussie partner-in-crime. The show uses the invasive Burmese python crisis in the Everglades as a brilliant metaphor for the invasive, predatory nature of economic struggle. It’s violent, weird, deeply satirical, and surprisingly heartfelt—a show that finds humor in the desperation of trying to make it, and pathos in the bonds formed in the struggle.
9. The Undeclared War (2022)
The Pitch: In 2024, a team of cyber analysts at GCHQ (the UK’s NSA) race to identify and stop a devastating malware attack during a national election, with a coding prodigy on the front lines.
Why You’re Missing It: This British drama is perhaps the most realistic and terrifying depiction of cyberwarfare ever put on screen. We see the attack not through explosions, but through lines of code, network maps, and frantic team huddles. Simon Pegg gives a subdued, powerful performance as a senior analyst, but the star is newcomer Hannah Khalique-Brown as Saara, the intern whose unique pattern-recognition skills become crucial. The show brilliantly visualizes coding and hacking through immersive graphics, making a potentially dry subject pulse with tension. It’s a sobering, intelligent thriller that understands the next world war will be fought in the digital realm, and the soldiers will be programmers.
10. Poker Face (2023-Present)
The Pitch: A woman with a supernatural ability to detect lies, Charlie Cale, hits the road in her Plymouth Barracuda, stumbling into a new murder mystery in each town she visits.
Why You’re Missing It: While it garnered critical acclaim, Poker Face still feels under-watched given its quality. Created by Rian Johnson, it is a loving, meticulous homage to the classic “howcatchem” detective shows of the 70s like Columbo. The genius twist: we see the murder happen at the start of each episode. The pleasure is not in the “who,” but in the “how”—watching the brilliant, blue-collar Charlie (Natasha Lyonne, in a role she was born to play) piece it together through observation, charm, and her unerring lie detector. The guest stars (Adrien Brody, Chloë Sevigny, Joseph Gordon-Levitt) are phenomenal, the period-specific soundtrack is impeccable, and each episode is a self-contained marvel of structure and character. It’s comfort food with razor-sharp writing, a celebration of procedural storytelling at its finest.
You May Also Like- Peacock : Start Streaming Today with This Simple Login Guide Visit : Peacocktv.com/tv
Conclusion: Peacock’s Hidden Identity
Peacock’s strength lies in this very curation of the specific, the bold, and the niche. It is a platform unafraid to house the punk-rock spirituality of Mrs. Davis alongside the dusty, obsessive archaeology of Oak Island. It supports the razor-sharp industry satire of Girls5eva and the quiet, revolutionary representation of Rutherford Falls. These shows may not have the billion-dollar budgets of Stranger Things, but they possess something more valuable: distinct, uncompromised voices.
In a streaming landscape often criticized for homogenized content, Peacock has become an unlikely haven for creators with singular visions. These ten shows represent the best of that offering—series that entertain, provoke, and resonate on a deeply human level. They are the conversations you’re not hearing at the virtual water cooler, the hidden gems that transform a streaming service from a mere utility into a destination for discovery. To miss them is to miss some of the most inventive, funny, and thought-provoking television being made today. So venture beyond the algorithm and into Peacock’s catalog; your next favorite show is waiting, undoubtedly underrated, but not for long.
